top of page

What is my coin worth?

18 hours ago
2 min read

“What is it worth?” is the question we hear most often, and it has no single answer. The chart below shows why. It plots 93 recent auction sales of one coin type, the serrate denarius of A. Postumius Albinus (Crawford 372/1, Rome, about 81 BC), recorded on ACSearch between 21 March 2023 and 7 October 2026.

The median sale was $191. Half the lots sold between $120 and $350. The full range ran from $36 to $2,069, so the most expensive coin brought about 57 times the price of the cheapest. All figures are hammer prices, the winning bid before the auction house adds its buyer’s fee.

Every one of these coins carries the same catalogue number, but no two are the same object. Roman mint workers struck each denarius by hand. They placed a heated silver blank between two engraved dies and hit the upper die with a hammer. The blank could land off center, the strike could be weak or doubled, and part of the design could fall off the flan (the metal disc).


Another interesting view : a rolling two-year median of since 2003, both types: each point is the median of the sales in that year and the year before. The shaded band is the rolling two-year middle half (25th to 75th percentile). Windows with fewer than ten sales are left out (first two years for 372/2) . 372/1 (Diana) 430 coins 372/2 (Hispania) 586 coins


For a comparison - perhaps interesting to look at Consumer Price Index (CPI).

The dies varied as well. Engravers cut each one by hand, and a single issue used many pairs of dies, so details of the portrait and lettering differ from die to die. Dies also wore down and cracked with use, and coins struck late in a die’s life show softer detail.


The coins have then had about 2,100 years to change further. Some circulated for decades and lost detail to wear. Others were buried soon after striking and survive close to their original state. Many show later damage: scratches, corrosion, cleaning marks, or test cuts made by ancient users checking that the silver ran all the way through.


Buyers weigh all of these features, along with toning, eye appeal, and a coin’s documented ownership history (its pedigree). Much of that weighing is a matter of judgment. Two specialists can examine the same coin and value it differently.


For this reason, a fair answer to “what is it worth?” is a range, with a specific coin’s place in that range set by its strike, its die, and its condition. This is my latest attempt to make data driven decisions: the middle half of this chart, $120 to $350, covers the typical example. Coins at either end sold for reasons particular to those individual pieces.


In Case you are curious - here's what the $4584 version of this coin looks like from a Leu Auction. Leu Numismatik, Auction 8, Lot 231 Even if I might not have bid on it, I can almost agree that this was a reasonable price. (not my coin)


 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating

Subscribe to Sulla Coins to share comments and receive notices when we post new content.

All rights reserved © 2026 Sulla80

bottom of page